Welcome to Jeff's Pizza
Jeff's Pizza, located at 400 E Main St in Knightstown, IN, is quickly becoming a local favorite. Renowned for its delicious offerings, the restaurant specializes in a variety of pizzas that cater to diverse tastes, from the indulgent all-meat option to tropical Hawaiian flavors. Patrons rave about the impressive salad bar, mouthwatering wings, and inventive dishes like the Chicken Quesadilla pizza. The friendly, hometown hospitality enhances the dining experience, making each visit enjoyable. With highlights such as generous portions and unique drinks like marshmallow Coke, Jeff's Pizza stands out as a must-try destination for pizza lovers.
Jeff's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
One of our new favorite pizza places. All meat pizza, add banana peppers, mushroom, extra cheese, and thick crust... delicious!!!!
We ordered from Jeff’s tonight and it was outstanding as always. We got a Hawaiian pizza and the Chicken Quesadilla pizza. Chef’s kiss.
I go here for their fresh salad bar and the wings are amazing! Great staff that still has that "hometown" friendliness. The pizza is good too! They have added some crustless choices that I am going to try next!
The food and service was great we enjoyed our dinner
First time there! It was great pizza! Nachos were huge for just a small! We had a wonderful waitress and the marshmallow coke was so yummy!!!!
First time here! My kids, niece's and I absolutely loved it. They have a good selection of different foods. The buffet/salad bar is amazing. Their pizza and bread sticks are great. Can't say enough how great their food is. The service is great as well and the people are very friendly. Definitely our new favorite pizza place in Knightstown.. We will be back soon!
This place is great! Nice, clean dining area. Buffet has a great salad bar. Thin crust pizza with generous toppings, fluffy breadsticks.
Every order I've ever placed at Jeff's, either dine-in or carry-out, has been filled with a smile. And it has been delicious! I recently ordered a calzone for the first time. It was beautiful! And HUGE!
Location
-
400 E Main St, Knightstown, IN 46148, United States Hotline: +1 765-345-5775
Welcome to the delightful world of Jeff's Pizza, nestled in the heart of Knightstown, Indiana. Located at 400 E Main St, this eatery has quickly carved a niche for itself as a go-to destination for pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike. With the warm and inviting atmosphere, Jeff's Pizza is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a community hub that embodies the "hometown" spirit.
Patrons rave about their experience with the variety of flavors and options available. One standout dish mentioned by customers is the all-meat pizza, which can be customized with delicious add-ons like banana peppers, mushrooms, and extra cheese to achieve the perfect bite. These hearty toppings combined with a thick crust truly craft a pizza experience worth savoring. As one satisfied customer, 'Sweetie 55', delightfully noted, it’s becoming one of their new favorite pizza joints.
Another crowd favorite includes the unique Hawaiian pizza and the adventurous Chicken Quesadilla pizza. These options are sure to entice those looking for something beyond traditional pizza offerings. Customer 'Ashley Jo Monger' described the latter as "outstanding," and it’s easy to see why — the creative fusion of flavors keeps diners coming back for more, echoing a culinary adventure that always hits the spot.
Additionally, Jeff’s Pizza offers more than just pizza. The fresh salad bar has become a go-to for individuals like 'Alan King', who appreciate the balance of freshness alongside hearty pizza dishes. And let’s not overlook the wings, which have garnered their own share of praise for being quite simply, "amazing". The restaurant's diverse menu truly caters to various tastes, ensuring everyone finds something to relish.
Customer service at Jeff's Pizza shines brightly, with staff members known for their friendly and welcoming demeanor. An experience shared by 'Jeffery Woodruff' confirms the excellent service, highlighting how it enhances the overall dining experience. Furthermore, new additions to their menu, such as crustless pizza options, keep things interesting and cater to those with dietary preferences.
If you're craving more than just pizza, the menu boasts great sides like hearty nachos that 'Breeanna Wright' noted were impressively large for a small order. To wash it down, try their inventive marshmallow coke, a delightful twist that showcases their creative flair.
In essence, Jeff's Pizza isn’t merely a restaurant; it’s a celebration of flavor, community, and exceptional dining. Whether for dinner with family or a casual lunch with friends, every visit promises a delicious array of flavors and an inviting atmosphere that is sure to entice you. If you haven’t already, make your way to Knightstown and discover the joy that awaits at Jeff's Pizza!